In 1297 Edward I's relationship with his subjects appears to have come
to an head. His barons disagreed with the military service he tried to
impose upon them, and were joined by the clergy in disputes over the taxes
Edward levied to fight wars in France and Scotland. This was a problem
for the king, as Edward was faced with the pressing need to defend his
territories, while easing the threat of civil war.
Edward signed the Conformation of Charters in 1297, which was basically
to re-established the Magna Carta and the charter of the forest, but also
stated military service could not be demanded without consent, and taxes
could not be levied without the consent of the community of the realm,
then only if the tax was seen to be profitable to the community.
The significance of the conformation of the charters has raised some
historical debates. It has been seen by historians, such as Rothwell, to
be the sign of the end of the importance of the charters, which can be
seen to decline in the minds of the barons until they became rarely in
use after Edward II's succession. This can be noted as a change in style
of the barons need to control the king, as different methods, such as the
ordinances, began to be frequently used. The Conformation of the charters
has also been seen by historians, such as Prestwich, not to be and end
but an beginning to the struggle between Edward and his barons, and the
king began to be seen to be separate from the crown.
How did the conformation of Charters effect Edward's polices in his
last years? Edward did become more careful in his actions, but he was not
completely restrained as the charters can make one believe, and saw it
to avoid the obligation the barons imposed by interpreting the conformations
in his own way. In 1298 Edward was able to avoid the issue of raising taxes
by claiming he would try to live of his own as long as he possibly could,
though at this time his treasuries were already empty. He did try to follow
this and to survive he sold much of his gold, leaving the crown bankrupt,
and sold royal forest land, which was seen to be in violation of the Charters.
It seems that, though Edward was placed under restraints, he still continued
to try to avoid the clauses, which did bring him into dispute with his
barons. Even though the Inpexiumus et confirmatios in 1300 bound him even
closer to the issues in the charters, by making Edward hold to every article
and clause within them, the confirmation of charters did not cause a complete
setback as edward was still able to move under his own free will. This
period can be seen to be an end to the major reforms of Edward's early
reign as he did have to spend his last years trying to avoid any more expansion
of the charters, but by the end of his reign and after the annulment of
the conformations in 1305 by the pope, the charters seemed to lose interest
for the barons who moved to other means to control the monarchy in Edward
II reign.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
-
1) Powicke, F. M, THIRTEENTH CENTURY, 1998
-
2) Prestwich, M, EDWARD I, Methuen, London, 1988
-
3) Rothwell, H 'Edward I and the struggle for the charters', p319-332,
in Hunt, R.W et al. (eds.), STUDIES IN MEDIEVAL HISTORY PRESENTED TO F.
M. POWICKE, Clarendon, Oxford, 1948
-
4) Salzman, L.F, EDWARD I, Constable, London, 1968
-- ------------
K.D.Mooney hiu45d@bangor.ac.uk |
|